Wisconsin Cheese
If you are ordering a gift, please click the SEND A GIFT on the top menu. Then select "Build a Gift"
This will allow you to ship to addresses besides yourself and include gift messages.
Tim Brennan is carrying on his family's tradition of buying direct from our state's best cheesemakers, many of them in his own backyard of Green County, WI.
Our Artisanal Wisconsin Cheese Collection features the classics like Aged Cheddars, Swiss Cheese, creamy Cheese Spreads, and, of course, Squeaky Cheese Curds! We also feature Skip's creations like Basil Farmer and Cranberry Cheddar.
Our cheese hand-selected, aged, cut and packaged in Monroe, WI.
-
Provolone
Provolone
Brennans MarketWisconsin Provolone Cheese A cheese closely related to Mozzarella, Provolone is distinguishable by its fuller flavors...
-
Amish Tomato Basil Jack Cheese
Amish Tomato Basil Jack Cheese
Brennans MarketAmish Tomato Basil Jack is a mild-tasting, creamy semi-soft cheese that is enhanced with the sweet flavor of basil an...
-
Smoked Pepper Jack
Smoked Pepper Jack
Brennans MarketWisconsin Smoked Pepper Jack Cheese Smoked Pepper Jack Cheese combines the mellow buttery taste and texture of Monter...
-
Amish White Cheddar
Amish White Cheddar
Brennans MarketAmish White Cheddar Cheese has a smooth, creamy texture with a nutty flavor. This is a great all-around cheddar that ...
-
Smoked Baby Swiss
Smoked Baby Swiss
Brennans MarketWisconsin Smoked Baby Swiss Cheese Wisconsin Cheesemakers traditionally produce Baby Swiss from whole milk, unlike tr...
-
Asiago
Asiago
Brennans MarketAsiago Wisconsin Cheese has a firm texture and sweet and nutty flavor. Asiago derives its name from a small town in ...
-
Gouda Original Marieke
Gouda Original Marieke
Brennans MarketWisconsin Made Original Gouda Cheese Creamy, buttery, and mild with slightly sweet notes. Pair with peach preserves a...
-
Swiss Emmentaler
Swiss Emmentaler
Brennans MarketMade from the raw milk of cows grazing in the Alps, this is the original "Swiss" cheese (holes and all) is aged 12 mo...
-
Amish Swiss Cheese
Amish Swiss Cheese
Brennans MarketA mild, nutty flavor and creamy texture are what make our Amish Swiss Cheese a standout. Its smooth consistency and d...
-
Butterkase
Butterkase
Brennans MarketWisconsin Butterkase Cheese Decadence is a word that comes to mind when indulging in this tasty treat. Just like the ...
-
Colby Swiss
Colby Swiss
Brennans MarketWisconsin Colby Swiss Cheese Created by Decatur Dairy's Master Cheesemaker Steve Stettler, Colby Swiss has a mild, cr...
-
Farmer's Cheese
Farmer's Cheese
Brennans MarketWisconsin Farmers' Cheese Our Diet Delite is a mild Farmer's cheese made with skim milk. It has a lower fat content. ...
-
Apple Jack
Apple Jack
Brennans MarketApple Jack Cheese is semi-soft (like Monterey Jack) and has a smooth and supple texture. Its flavor is mild and sweet...
-
Blazing Buffalo Cheddar
Blazing Buffalo Cheddar
Brennans MarketBlazing Buffalo Cheddar Cheddar cheese with the zesty kick of buffalo wings. Add it to a dip to spice it up, grate it...
-
Glarner Swiss
Glarner Swiss
Brennans MarketWisconsin Glarner Swiss Cheese Glarner Swiss has a buttery, slightly sweet flavor, with a creamy texture. 100% Wisco...
-
Gouda Smoked Marieke
Gouda Smoked Marieke
Brennans MarketWisconsin Smoked Gouda Marieke Rich and full-flavored; gently smoked over natural hickory wood. Pair with dried cherr...
-
American Grana
American Grana
Brennans MarketAmerican Grana American Grana is based on the famous Grana Padano of Italy. Made from raw cow’s milk, it is aged for...
-
Onion Brick
Onion Brick
Brennans MarketWisconsin Onion Brick Cheese A mild, smooth, semi-soft cheese with mild onion flavor. Great for melting or slicing. H...
-
Monterey Jack
Monterey Jack
Brennans MarketWisconsin Monterey Jack Cheese Scotsman David Jacks first produced Monterey Jack in Monterey, California in the 1890s...
-
Medium Brick- Yellow
Medium Brick- Yellow
Brennans MarketWisconsin Medium Brick Cheese A full, creamy, medium brick with a bit of tang. 100% Wisconsin Cheese Net wt: 14.4oz B...
-
Chipotle Jack
Chipotle Jack
Brennans MarketWisconsin Chipolte Jack A derivative of Monterey Jack, Wisconsin Chipotle Jack is flavored with chipotle, a smoke-dri...
-
Foil Brick
Foil Brick
Brennans MarketWisconsin Foil Brick Cheese Wisconsin smear-ripened brick aged for maximum flavor. Very pungent, but great according ...
-
Medium Aged Block Swiss
Medium Aged Block Swiss
Brennans MarketWisconsin Medium Aged Block Swiss Cheese is a full-flavored, buttery, nutty cheese that is aged 6-8 months. Wisconsin...
-
Havarti Pepper
Havarti Pepper
Brennans MarketWisconsin Pepper Havarti Cheese Our Pepper Havarti is buttery and creamy with a burst of heat. Perfect with any Mexi...
-
Mozzarella - Part Skim
Mozzarella - Part Skim
Brennans MarketWisconsin Part-Skim Mozzarella Cheese What's the difference between whole milk and part-skim Mozzarella? Part-Skim M...
-
Mango Fire Cheddar
Mango Fire Cheddar
Brennans MarketMango Fire Cheddar Creamy Cheddar with Habanero and Sweet Mangoes. Great for charcuterie boards, chicken quesadillas...
-
Smoked Mild Swiss
Smoked Mild Swiss
Brennans MarketWisconsin Smoked Mild Swiss Cheese A full-flavored, buttery, nutty cheese that is aged 2-3 months and smoked for a bo...
-
Smoked Brick
Smoked Brick
Brennans MarketWisconsin Smoked Brick Cheese Brick is a Wisconsin original, first made by John Jossi around 1877. Brick was named fo...
-
Jalapeño Gouda
Jalapeño Gouda
Brennans MarketWisconsin Gouda with Gouda Jalapeño Cheese Velvety and mellow Gouda elevated by the fresh bite of jalapeño peppers. ...
-
Pinnacle Gouda (Aged 9-12 Months)
Pinnacle Gouda (Aged 9-12 Months)
Brennans MarketPinnacle Gouda (Aged 9-12 Months) Deep nuanced aromas bring this Aged Gouda to a delectable level. Slightly crystaliz...
-
Holy Trinity Mélange Gouda
Holy Trinity Mélange Gouda
Brennans MarketWisconsin Gouda Holy Trinity Mélange Cheese An aromatic flavor base similar to mirepoix that swaps out the carrot for...
-
Honey Clover Gouda
Honey Clover Gouda
Brennans MarketWisconsin Gouda with Honey Clover Cheese A sweet yet earthy aroma combines with the smooth richness of this Gouda. No...































