Shop All- Non-Gift

You are in the right place if you're shopping for yourself.
If you want to send a gift, please click "Send a Gift" on the main menu. When you send a gift, you can include a gift message and product pricing is removed.
Browse our full online collection of products. Delivered to your door!
Cold Weather Shipping - November 1- March 31
We don't use any ice packs to ship cheese. Cheese products are perishable and must be delivered promptly to arrive in good condition, particularly during warmer weather (above 70 degrees F). When shipping to warm-weather climates, we recommend shipping Next Day Air or 2nd Day Air for all orders outside the one or two-day delivery zone. We are not responsible for damage due to weather.
Cold Weather Packaging and Handling Fee: We charge an $8 packaging and handling fee for all shipments except our premade holiday cheese boxes.
See zone chart here.
-
Strawberry-Rhubarb Spreadable FruitStrawberry-Rhubarb Spreadable FruitBrennans Market
Brennan's Strawberry-Rhubarb Spreadable Fruit- JUST LIKE GRANDMA USED TO MAKE Our Strawberry-Rhubarb Spread is packed...
-
Terrapin Ridge Dill Pickle MustardTerrapin Ridge Dill Pickle MustardTerrapin Ridge
Terrapin Ridge Dill Pickle Mustard Mouthwatering dill pickles and smooth Dijon... it's the mustard you've been waitin...
-
Goat Milk GoudaGoat Milk GoudaBrennans Market
Brennan's Wisconsin Goat Milk Gouda Cheese A wonderful cheese with a mild, sweet, caramel flavor balanced by a slight...
-
Low Sodium/ Low-Fat CheddarLow Sodium/ Low-Fat CheddarBrennans Market
Low Sodium/ Low-Fat Cheddar-- 100% Wisconsin Cheese Net wt: 11.2oz Because our cheese is hand-cut, your cheese may ar...
-
Monterey JackMonterey JackBrennans Market
Wisconsin Monterey Jack Cheese Scotsman David Jacks first produced Monterey Jack in Monterey, California in the 1890s...
-
Pico de Gallo (Salsa Cheddar)Pico de Gallo (Salsa Cheddar)Brennans Market
Wisconsin Salsa Cheddar Cheese Zesty, but not hot. This Cheddar is great melted on just about anything. 100% Wiscons...
-
Apple ButterApple ButterBrennans Market
Brennan's Apple Butter- JUST LIKE GRANDMA USED TO MAKE! JUST LIKE GRANDMA USED TO MAKE! Our Apple Butter captures the...
-
Havarti CarawayHavarti CarawayBrennans Market
Wisconsin Caraway Havarti Cheese Our Caraway Havarti is buttery and creamy with anise-like caraway seeds. Great paire...
-
Colby SwissColby SwissBrennans Market
Wisconsin Colby Swiss Cheese Created by Decatur Dairy's Master Cheesemaker Steve Stettler, Colby Swiss has a mild, cr...
-
Amish Swiss CheeseAmish Swiss CheeseBrennans Market
A mild, nutty flavor and creamy texture are what make our Amish Swiss Cheese a standout. Its smooth consistency and d...
-
Smoked Pepper JackSmoked Pepper JackBrennans Market
Wisconsin Smoked Pepper Jack Cheese Smoked Pepper Jack Cheese combines the mellow buttery taste and texture of Monter...
-
Raspberry-Rhubarb Spreadable FruitRaspberry-Rhubarb Spreadable FruitBrennans Market
Brennan's Raspberry-Rhubarb Spreadable Fruit- JUST LIKE GRANDMA USED TO MAKE Our Raspberry-Rhubarb Spread is packed w...
-
Havarti with Horseradish & ChiveHavarti with Horseradish & ChiveBrennans Market
Wisconsin Horseradish and Chive Havarti Cheese A smooth, buttery flavor with a kick –our Horseradish Havarti has been...
-
Rustic Italian Balsamic & CipolineRustic Italian Balsamic & CipolineBrennans Market
Wisconsin Balsamic and Cipoline Rustic Italian Cheese Rustic Italian This flavor packed cheese firm with the granular...
-
Blackberry ButterBlackberry ButterBrennans Market
Brennan's Blackberry Butter- JUST LIKE GRANDMA USED TO MAKE! Our Blackberry Butter tastes like summer in a jar. A y...
-
Foenugreek GoudaFoenugreek GoudaBrennans Market
Wisconsin Gouda with Foenugreek Cheese Sweet and nutty with flavor notes reminiscent of maple syrup. Pair with toaste...
-
Brennan's Rye CrackersBrennan's Rye CrackersBrennans Market
Brennan's Rye Crackers Locally-made, by our friends at Potter's If you love caraway rye bread you will love this crac...
-
Low-Sugar Apple ButterLow-Sugar Apple ButterBrennans Market
Brennan's Low-Sugar Apple Butter-- JUST LIKE GRANDMA USED TO MAKE! Our Low-Sugar Apple Butter captures the flavors of...
-
Usigner's Low-Fat Beef Summer SausageUsigner's Low-Fat Beef Summer SausageUsinger's
Usigner's Low-Fat Beef Summer Sausage This Sausage contains 40% less fat than their regular Beef Summer. Crafted with...
-
Salami CheeseSalami CheeseBrennans Market
You only need the crackers with cheese, folks. Net wt: 9.6oz Because our cheese is hand cut, your cheese may arrive ...
-
Farmer's CheeseFarmer's CheeseBrennans Market
Wisconsin Farmers' Cheese Our Diet Delite is a mild Farmer's cheese made with skim milk. It has a lower fat content. ...
-
Smoked Baby SwissSmoked Baby SwissBrennans Market
Wisconsin Smoked Baby Swiss Cheese Wisconsin Cheesemakers traditionally produce Baby Swiss from whole milk, unlike tr...
-
Corn RelishCorn RelishBrennans Market
Brennan's Corn Relish - JUST LIKE GRANDMA USED TO MAKE! Enjoy on a burger with tomatoes and avocados. Mix with sour c...
-
Smoked Sweet SwissSmoked Sweet SwissBrennans Market
Wisconsin Smoked Sweet Swiss Cheese Sweet Swiss, a rind cheese produced in Wisconsin, is a cross between Baby Swiss a...
-
Foil BrickFoil BrickBrennans Market
Wisconsin Foil Brick Cheese Wisconsin smear-ripened brick aged for maximum flavor. Very pungent, but great according ...
-
ProvoloneProvoloneBrennans Market
Wisconsin Provolone Cheese A cheese closely related to Mozzarella, Provolone is distinguishable by its fuller flavors...
-
Havarti HerbHavarti HerbBrennans Market
Wisconsin Herb Havarti Cheese Our Herb Havarti is buttery and creamy with Italian flavors. Great on a cheeseboard or ...
-
Green Wrap EdamGreen Wrap EdamBrennans Market
Wisconsin Edam Cheese Edam is nutty and slightly sweet. It has a firmer texture than its close relative, Gouda. Enjo...
-
Wild Huckleberry PreservesWild Huckleberry PreservesBrennans Market
Wild Huckleberry Preserves- JUST LIKE GRANDMA USED TO MAKE What is a Huckleberry? A huckleberry is a small, round, ed...
-
Terrapin Ridge Sweet Beet & Horseradish MustardTerrapin Ridge Sweet Beet & Horseradish MustardTerrapin Ridge
Terrapin Ridge Sweet Beet & Horseradish Mustard A perfect marriage of beets and horseradish combined with whole-g...
-
Double Berry Spreadable FruitDouble Berry Spreadable FruitBrennans Market
Brennan's Double Berry Spreadable Fruit- JUST LIKE GRANDMA USED TO MAKE! Our Double Berry Spread is a wicked combinat...
-
Cherry Spreadable FruitCherry Spreadable FruitBrennans Market
Brennan's Cherry Spreadable Fruit- JUST LIKE GRANDMA USED TO MAKE Our Cherry Spread is packed with the flavor of summ...
-
Medium Brick- YellowMedium Brick- YellowBrennans Market
Wisconsin Medium Brick Cheese A full, creamy, medium brick with a bit of tang. 100% Wisconsin Cheese Net wt: 14.4oz B...
-
Low Sodium/ Low Fat MuensterLow Sodium/ Low Fat MuensterBrennans Market
Low Sodium/ Low Fat Muenster- 100% Wisconsin Cheese Net wt: 12.8oz Because our cheese is hand cut, your cheese may ar...
-
Rustic ItalianRustic ItalianBrennans Market
Wisconsin Rustic Italian Cheese Wisconsin's answer to Parmesan Reggiano. Our Rustic Italian Cheese is a semi-firm che...