Skip to content

Collection:

Please Note: Warm Weather Packaging Required on all Cheese & Sausage Orders March 26-October 31*. Fees apply

Brennans Market
    • Build a Gift
    • Send a Gift Card
    • Shipping and Delivery Info
    Send a Gift 🎁
    • Wisconsin Cheese
    • Sausage
    • Spreadable Fruit
    • Fruit Butters
    • Fruit Preserves
    • Relish and Salsa
    • Granola
    • Mustard and Crackers
    • Pancake & Baking Mixes
    • Coffee
    • Shop All- Non-Gift
    • Shipping and Delivery Info
    Shop Non-Gift
    • Seasonal Produce
    • Spring Greenhouse
    • Our Cheeses
    • Butcher Shop & Deli
    • Events
    • Bakery
    • Specialty Food
    • Craft Beer
    • Craft Spirits & Liquor
    • Fruit Gift Baskets
    • Wine
    • Curbside Pickup
    At the Market Now
  • Cafe Menu
    • Market/Contact Info
    • Brennan's Blog
    • Market Recipes
    • Our History
    • Employment
    Contact Us
Search Log in Cart
Number of items in your cart: 0

Menu

    • Build a Gift
    • Send a Gift Card
    • Shipping and Delivery Info
    Send a Gift 🎁
    • Wisconsin Cheese
    • Sausage
    • Spreadable Fruit
    • Fruit Butters
    • Fruit Preserves
    • Relish and Salsa
    • Granola
    • Mustard and Crackers
    • Pancake & Baking Mixes
    • Coffee
    • Shop All- Non-Gift
    • Shipping and Delivery Info
    Shop Non-Gift
    • Seasonal Produce
    • Spring Greenhouse
    • Our Cheeses
    • Butcher Shop & Deli
    • Events
    • Bakery
    • Specialty Food
    • Craft Beer
    • Craft Spirits & Liquor
    • Fruit Gift Baskets
    • Wine
    • Curbside Pickup
    At the Market Now
  • Cafe Menu
    • Market/Contact Info
    • Brennan's Blog
    • Market Recipes
    • Our History
    • Employment
    Contact Us
  • Log in
4-Year Aged Cheddar - Brennans Market

4-Year Aged Wisconsin Cheddar

4-Year Aged Wisconsin Cheddar

Vendor
Brennans Market
Ready to Ship
$12.99
Ready to Ship
Sale price
$12.99
Sale Ready to Ship
Unit price
/per 
Error Quantity must be 1 or more

4-Year Aged Wisconsin Cheddar Cheese

Our 4-Year Aged Cheddar is rich, beefy cheddar has a granular texture. Cheddar is at its peak of sharpness between three and five years. 

What Happens When Cheddar Ages?

As Cheddar ages it releases extra moisture, really concentrating and focusing the flavors. The loss of moisture also changes the texture. The cheese will become crumblier and begin to form flavor crystals.

What's the Difference Between Your Aged Cheddars?

We think the best way to experience the difference between our Aged Cheddars is to try them side-by-side.  A vertical Cheddar tasting!

100% Wisconsin Cheese

Net wt: 13.87oz

Because our cheese is hand-cut, your cheese may arrive slightly more or slightly less than listed net weight.

Pairing

Paring: 4-Year Aged Wisconsin Cheddar

Beer: off-dry, mature beverages that have just a touch of sweetness

  • Saison Ale
  • Cider
  • Bock 
  • Belgian Ale

Wine: 

  • Chardonnay
  • Champagne
  • Syrah
  • Pinot Noir
  • Chianti

Spirits: Bourbon & Single Malt Scotch

Serving

Serving 4-Year Aged Wisconsin Cheddar

  • Leave the melty, ooey-gooey dishes to young cheddars.
  • Aged cheddar likes to be eaten with a little sticky sweetness, so serve it with a homemade jam, chutney, or honey. We love it paired with Tait Farms Mango, Cranberry or Apple Chutney, Terrapin Ridge Champagne Honey Mustard, Concord Farms Raw Honey, or our own Apple Butter. 
  • Pair with sweet pickles or pickled beets. 
  • It makes for a classic English Ploughman’s lunch (cheese, fruit, and veggie board). 
  • Team with big, peppery green salads, a warm grain salad (barley, farro, quinoa), or most hearty soups like Potato Cheddar

Ingredients

Ingredients: Pasteurized milk, cultures, vegetable enzymes, salt, annatto (if colored; a vegetable extract)

  • Share Share on Facebook
  • Tweet Tweet on Twitter
  • Pin it Pin on Pinterest

Brennans Market

We are located at
8210 Watts Road
Madison, WI 53719

(608) 833-2893
info@brennansmarket.com

Store Hours: Monday - Friday 8am - 8pm Saturday - Sunday 8am-6pm

Wisconsin's Favorite Specialty Market

Authentic Wisconsin cheese, meats and specialty grocery. Seasonal fruits and vegetables from local farms. Wine, Craft Beer & Spirits.

Create gift boxes to be shipped anywhere in the US. Shop online or visit us at our brick-and-mortar location. Curbside pickup available.

Newsletter

Quick links

  • Search
  • Terms of Service
  • Refund policy
  • Do not sell my personal information
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Instagram
© 2022, Brennans Market Powered by Shopify
Payment methods accepted
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Discover
  • JCB
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Venmo
  • Visa
  • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
  • Press the space key then arrow keys to make a selection.